Dead Eye Tom:Yah, your right never owned one, but have fired one belonging to a friend. It did go bang. I found the trigger rough and was not fond of the blowback action and stiff slide. That is probably the same reason I found it a little top heavy for my balance. I can't see the unit as an EDC as I found it a little bulky. Down the hallway at 3:00 AM I'm with you, but I would still reach for my 1911 first. Sorry to come off snobby, I generally like any gun.
DET
I agree that the trigger on a HP is not as fine, lite, easy as what you would find even on a stock milspec 1911 but they are not bad either.
At the range last weekend. We were shooting a KelTek P32, Walther P22 and the HP C9.
All guns properly sighted and working properly. But the HP C9 was the gun that everyone shot most accurately with.
The blowback operation of the HP was different but I try to look at it like this. If you can learn to shoot a HP and be very accurate with it, it will greatly help your accuracy with a locked breach or one of the rotating locking barrel designs. If you have learned to lock your wrist to keep the blowback action working properly it will also help keep the barrel down helping you in a faster recovery for follow up shot and keeping your gun on target for better shot placement.
I find this to be true with me. If I shoot my HP frequently and then switch over to another gun, my shot placement is greatly improved.
Topheavy, yah it is but it grows on you like a good hangover and then you learn to like it because of all the fun you have with it.
Sorry to come off snobby, I generally like any gun.
No problem. I use to be the same about Glocks and still don't like Tauruses. The Taurus issue is from problems I had with them and Glock is a non issue any more.

God Bless The USA
Proudly Politically Incorrect.